Roll over or click image to zoom in

ST JOHNS BAY RUM AFTER SHAVE (Multiple Sizes Available)

St Johns
St Johns Bay Rum® is known to experts throughout the world as one of the best bay rum aftershave colognes. Our formula, for almost 70 years, has been to blend...
customers are viewing this product
  • St Johns Bay Rum® is known to experts throughout the world as one of the best bay rum aftershave colognes.

    Our formula, for almost 70 years, has been to blend the richest West Indian Bay Leaf Oils and premium Caribbean fragrances to create a natural, manly essence of eucalyptus, cloves, and Caribbean spices.  

    Each bottle of St Johns Bay Rum® is handcrafted in small batches at our St Johns Fragrance Factory in St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands.

    St Johns Bay Rum®   A spicy, warm, rich and distinctively masculine scent that's a classic for every generation.

    Available in:  4 oz. Splash $50.00 | 4 oz. Spray  $50.00 | 8 oz. Splash $75.00

Return Policy

We’ll accept return requests for items that are unopened, unused, with the original tags still intact. The product(s) must be in their original packaging, if applicable, in the same condition it was received. We do not accept returns for perishable items, intimate items, gift cards and beauty items. If you wish to return your item, we must receive your request within 14 days of the date you received your item.


Once we receive your returned item, our team will review your request and inspect the item. We will send you an email to confirm that we’ve received your item and are processing your request. We’ll follow up with another email once the request has been processed to let you know if your return was approved. If approved, the money will be refunded to your original method of payment within two weeks. All payment companies are different in the amount of time it takes to confirm a payment, so it will likely take a minimum of a few days for the refund to show up in your bank statement.


In the unlikely event that you receive a damaged or defective item, we’re happy to exchange the item for a new one. Please email within 30 days of receiving your product to begin the process.

Return Shipping

After you’ve submitted a return request to, we will send you a PDF of a return shipping label. Please print it out and affix to your package. For returning undamaged and unused items, you are responsible for paying for the return shipping costs. We will deduct the cost of return shipping from your refund. For returning goods that arrived damaged or the wrong item sent by us, we will cover the cost of return shipping as well as giving you an intact item or a full refund.

Have question? Ask an Beauty Expert

Customer Reviews

Based on 21 reviews
Deanna Klosinski
St Johns Bay Rum

Always my husband’s choice. And I love the smell on him.

Diane Cianfrani

ST JOHNS BAY RUM AFTER SHAVE (Multiple Sizes Available)

Joe C Thomas
$80.00 Wasted

Some how the formula has been changed, and this is not the same formula as when I first started buying St Johns bay rum. Needless to say I don't care for this last purchase.

catherine Indianos
opened bottle!!!

The bottle had been previously opened. The wrap on the bottle was opened and most of the after shave had spilt out. When I called and finally got in touch with someone, the guy said dont pay for it, just dispute it with your credit card company. I dont know, something very sketchy is happening with Eisler, I will never, I mean NEVER order anything from them again!!!!

Lester Hatcher

Very good service and
St. John's Bay Rum is the best. Not familiar with the other After Shave Cologne. Send me samples. Thanks

You have successfully subscribed!